Gold Scammer List: How to Avoid Getting Ripped Off
Gold and silver attract honest sellers and dishonest ones, and the dishonest ones tend to aim at retirement savings. This page lists precious metals sellers that federal regulators have charged or won judgments against, each linked to the regulator's own release. It also covers the courier scams that don't involve a dealer at all, the warning signs these cases share, and where to check a seller and report a problem.
Quick answer: Regulators have brought cases against several gold and silver sellers, including Metals.com (TMTE Inc.), Red Rock Secured, Regal Assets and Safeguard Metals. The common thread is retirement savers being sold metal at prices far above its value, or not getting metal at all. Separately, no government agency ever asks anyone to buy gold and hand it to a courier.
Key takeaways
- The CFTC said in March 2024 that over the past decade it had brought numerous cases against dealers alleged to have collectively sold over $500 million of overpriced metals.
- The cases below share patterns: older customers, retirement accounts, scare talk about other savings, and prices far above the metal's value.
- The FBI's 2025 internet crime report counted about 725 gold courier scam complaints, with $311.8 million in losses.
- The CFTC and FINRA point out that no federal agency regulates retail metal dealers, so checking a seller is largely up to the buyer.
- No legitimate agency will tell you to buy gold and give it to someone, and none charges you to recover lost money.
How gold scams work
The cases regulators describe fall into a few patterns.
Overpriced metal. The seller is real and the metal is real, but the price is far above the metal's worth. In the Red Rock Secured case, for example, the CFTC described coins worth about $30 million for which customers paid over $69 million.
No metal at all. The seller takes money for metal it says it is buying and storing, and doesn't buy it. In one case described by the CFTC, Southern Trust Metals claimed to buy physical metal held overseas, but the CFTC says no metals were purchased or sold.
Financed or leveraged deals. The buyer puts down part of the price and the seller "finances" the rest, holding the metal. The CFTC says it is against the law for dealers to offer these purchases unless the metal is delivered within 28 days.
Courier scams. These don't involve a dealer. A caller poses as tech support or a government agency, says your accounts have been compromised, and tells you to turn your savings into gold bars or cash for safekeeping. A courier then collects it. The FBI warned in January 2024 that losses of this kind topped $55 million from May to December 2023. Its 2025 annual report counted about 725 gold courier complaints with $311.8 million in losses.
Counterfeits. The FBI warned in 2021 that counterfeit coins, including bullion, were being sold on online auction, social media and retail websites.
Red flags
These warning signs come from the regulators' own releases and advisories:
- Scare talk about your other savings. In the Safeguard Metals case, the CFTC said customers were lured with false claims about the risk of their traditional retirement accounts.
- Coins priced far above their metal value. That runs through the Metals.com, Red Rock and Safeguard cases.
- Promises of big returns with little risk, or guarantees that limit your losses. The CFTC's advisory warns against both.
- Financing that keeps your metal with the seller beyond 28 days.
- Anyone claiming to be the government who asks you to buy gold, withdraw cash or "move your money to protect it". The FTC says each of these is a scam.
- A seller you can't trace. The CFTC and FINRA suggest checking a dealer's physical address, how long it has operated, and the names of its owners and salespeople for past complaints.
The CFTC and FINRA also note that some fraudulent dealers have charged spreads, meaning the gap between the buying and selling price, of more than 300 percent, while other dealers may charge less than 20 percent. A seller who won't tell you its buy and sell price for the same coin is a warning in itself.
The gold scammer list
Every row links to a federal regulator's release. Words such as "alleged" mean the regulator made a claim that a court had not decided when the release was published. Judgments are stated as the regulator reported them.
| Firm | Regulator | Year | What the regulator said | Release |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TMTE Inc., doing business as Metals.com, Chase Metals and Barrick Capital | CFTC, with 30 state regulators | 2020 | Alleged it took over $185 million from at least 1,600 people, more than $140 million of it retirement savings, targeting older customers, with prices averaging 100 percent to more than 300 percent over market | CFTC release 8254-20 |
| Red Rock Secured | SEC | 2024 | Final judgment of $76.4 million in total; the SEC said at least 700 people lost more than $50 million | SEC release LR-25996 |
| Red Rock Secured | CFTC | 2024 | Court ordered over $56 million in restitution, disgorgement and penalties; at least 950 customers | CFTC release 8898-24 |
| Regal Assets | CFTC, with California's DFPI | 2023 | Alleged it misappropriated more than $21 million from more than 120 customers, mostly in retirement accounts | CFTC release 8791-23 |
| Regal Assets | CFTC | 2024 | Default judgments: $21.9 million in restitution and $27.3 million in civil penalties | CFTC release 9001-24 |
| Safeguard Metals | CFTC | 2025 | Court ordered $25.6 million in restitution and a $25.6 million civil penalty; more than 450 customers, about $68 million | CFTC release 9139-25 |
Metals.com (TMTE Inc.). The CFTC filed this case jointly with 30 state regulators in September 2020 in federal court in Texas, against the company and two individuals, Lucas Asher and Simon Batashvili. A temporary restraining order was issued and a receiver appointed. The "Chase Metals" name in this case has nothing to do with Chase bank. The allegations had not been proved when the release was issued.
Red Rock Secured. The SEC said customers were told they would pay 1 to 5 percent above the metal's value, when the real figure was as much as 130 percent. The SEC release states that Red Rock now operates under the name American Coin Co.
Regal Assets. The CFTC and California's Department of Financial Protection and Innovation said the firm and two individuals used customer money for business expenses, salaries and bonuses, made "Ponzi-like" payments to older customers with new customers' money, and forged documents. The 2024 judgments were default judgments, meaning the defendants did not contest them.
Safeguard Metals. In November 2025 the CFTC announced a federal court order against Safeguard Metals LLC and Jeffrey Ikahn: $25.6 million of restitution plus a civil penalty of the same size. The CFTC said the firm targeted elderly and retirement-age customers and sold silver coins at inflated prices while misrepresenting how much it added.
This list is not complete. It covers cases we have read on the regulators' own sites. A firm missing from it is not cleared by its absence.
How to check a seller
Before you send money, run these free checks:
- CFTC's registration check. The CFTC's "check" page links to NFA BASIC, the SEC's adviser search, FINRA BrokerCheck and the CFTC's RED List.
- NFA BASIC. Search a firm or person by name for registration and disciplinary history. Because most retail coin dealers don't have to register, a dealer's absence from BASIC isn't proof of fraud. BASIC matters most for anyone selling financed or leveraged metal.
- Your state securities regulator. NASAA's site lists every state regulator. The CFTC and FINRA also suggest asking your state attorney general about complaints.
- The Better Business Bureau. Look up the seller's profile and complaint history, and check BBB Scam Tracker. The FBI suggests checking BBB complaints before buying coins.
- A web search of the owners' names, with words like "complaint" or "lawsuit".
Preventing it
A few habits close off most of these schemes:
- Get every price in writing: the price per coin, the gold or silver price at that moment, and what the seller would pay you to buy the coin back the same day.
- Prefer standard bullion coins and bars whose weight and purity the mint publishes, if what you want is metal rather than a collectible. Check what you're sold against the mint's own page.
- Never let anyone rush you into moving retirement money. A legitimate company will wait while you check it.
- Hang up on unexpected callers who say your accounts are compromised. Call your bank on the number you already have.
- Talk it over with someone you trust, as the FTC suggests, before moving savings.
If you're buying physical metal outright, our list of banks that sell gold coins and our comparison of APMEX and JM Bullion show what established sellers publish about their rules. Our Walmart coins guide explains how to check a Marketplace seller.
Reporting a scam and legal recourse
If you think you've been targeted or have lost money:
- FBI: report at ic3.gov, including transaction details, as the FBI's courier-scam notice advises.
- FTC: report at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
- CFTC: report fraud involving metals sellers to the CFTC.
- Your state attorney general and state securities regulator.
- People 60 and over can call the Department of Justice's Elder Justice Hotline at 1-833-FRAUD-11 (1-833-372-8311).
- Your bank or card company, as fast as possible, about any payment you made.
- Counterfeit coins or bullion: the FBI's 2021 notice says to report them to the Anti-Counterfeiting Task Force.
Beware of recovery scams. The CFTC warns of recovery frauds that target people already harmed by another fraud, offering to get their money back for a fee. The FTC says never to pay up front for help getting a refund. The FBI says its complaint center will never ask for payment to recover lost funds. The CFTC advises checking any such offer by going to the agency's or court's own website, or calling the agency yourself.
What recovery looks like. In the cases above, courts ordered restitution, but a court order is not the same as money collected. A licensed attorney can tell you whether a private claim makes sense in your situation.
Buying from an established company
The best defense is a seller with a long public record you can check. If your interest is gold inside a retirement account, our guides to how a gold IRA works and our ranking of gold IRA companies explain what a legitimate setup looks like: a custodian that allows physical metal, an approved depository, and metal that the law allows in an IRA.
Augusta Precious Metals is our top pick. Augusta holds an A+ grade from the BBB and has been accredited since 2015, per its BBB profile as of November 12, 2026. Its regulatory record includes a 2019 Minnesota consent order over selling bullion in the state before registering as a dealer, a registration matter that many dealers share, as our Augusta review explains. Augusta's own FAQ also lists promises that IRA metal can simply be stored at home among its warning signs. It isn't for everyone: Augusta states a standard minimum first purchase of $50,000, through an IRA or with personal funds, so smaller buyers will need a different seller.
FAQ
How do I know if a gold dealer is legitimate?
Check its physical address and how long it has operated, search its owners' names for complaints, look up its BBB profile, and ask your state securities regulator or attorney general. If it sells financed metal, check NFA BASIC too.
Will the government ever ask me to buy gold?
No. The FTC says real government agents aren't asking anyone to buy and deliver gold bars, and the FBI says government and law enforcement will never ask you to send cash or precious metals by mail, shipping or courier.
What happened to Red Rock Secured?
The SEC obtained a final judgment of $76.4 million in total in April 2024, and the CFTC obtained over $56 million in court-ordered payments. The SEC release states the firm now operates as American Coin Co.
Can I get my money back from a gold scam?
Sometimes, through a court-ordered restitution process, but not always. Report it quickly, and never pay anyone who offers to recover your money for a fee.
Is buying gold from a TV or radio ad a scam?
Not necessarily. Advertising alone doesn't tell you either way. The checks are the same: the seller's record, written prices, and what it pays to buy the metal back.
Sources
- CFTC: precious metals dealer cases (March 2024)
- CFTC complaint against TMTE Inc. (Metals.com)
- SEC on the Red Rock Secured judgment
- CFTC on the Red Rock Secured order
- CFTC complaint against Regal Assets
- CFTC on the Regal Assets default judgments
- CFTC on the Safeguard Metals order
- CFTC advisory on gold and safety
- CFTC: precious metal frauds
- CFTC and FINRA: 10 things to know about metals
- CFTC: check registration and backgrounds
- CFTC: recovery frauds
- NFA BASIC
- NASAA: contact your regulator
- BBB Scam Tracker
- FTC: government agents aren't asking you to buy gold bars
- FTC: scammers who say they can help you recover money
- FBI IC3: courier scams warning (January 2024)
- FBI IC3: tech support and government impersonation
- FBI IC3: counterfeit coins warning (2021)
- FBI IC3: recovery scam warning (2025)
- FBI IC3: 2025 Internet Crime Report
- BBB: Augusta Precious Metals profile
- Augusta Precious Metals: FAQ
Links to Augusta Precious Metals and Goldco are affiliate links: the site may be paid when a reader contacts them. Our disclosure.