American Gold Eagle vs Gold Buffalo: A Comparison Guide

Disclosure: If you invest through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Last Updated: March 23, 2024

Interested in investing in gold but not sure where to start? American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos are two popular options worth considering.

We will explore the history, differences, and similarities between these two iconic gold coins. From design and purity to investment value and market trends, we will break down everything you need to know to make an informed decision.

Discover which one you should invest in by reading on!

What Are American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos?

American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos are iconic coins minted by the United States Mint, sought after by both collectors and investors for their investment potential and historical significance in the world of precious metals.

The American Gold Eagles, first introduced in 1986, feature a design inspired by the famous Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle coin, making them a favorite among numismatic enthusiasts. On the other hand, the Gold Buffalos, introduced in 2006, pay tribute to the historic Buffalo Nickel. These coins not only hold intrinsic value for their gold content but also serve as a piece of American history. Their limited mintages and changing designs add an element of exclusivity, driving their popularity in the numismatic and investment communities.

What Is the History of American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos?

The history of American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos traces back to the Coinage Act, solidifying their status as government-backed coins with a rich minting history that reflects the legacy of American coinage.

These iconic coins were first authorized by the United States Congress in 1985 under the Bullion Coin Act of 1985. The American Gold Eagle was introduced as a means of allowing investors to easily invest in gold while also symbolizing the country’s rich heritage and national pride.

In contrast, the Gold Buffalo, first minted in 2006, pays homage to the historic Buffalo Nickel design created by James Earle Fraser in 1913. Both coins have become popular among collectors and investors alike due to their intrinsic value and historical significance.

What Are the Differences Between American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos?

When comparing American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, key differences emerge in their purity, weight specifications, and design variations, offering collectors and investors distinct choices in the realm of precious metal coins.

American Gold Eagles, minted at the United States Mint, boast a purity of 91.67%, containing 3% silver and 5.33% copper to improve durability.

On the other hand, Gold Buffalos are composed of 99.99% pure gold, making them a favorite among those seeking the highest gold content in their investments.

In terms of weight, American Gold Eagles come in various options ranging from 1/10 oz to 1 oz, whereas Gold Buffalos are typically only available in 1 oz increments.

These differences in composition and weight can significantly influence the appeal and value of these coins for collectors and investors alike.


The design of American Gold Eagles embodies iconic American symbols and historical figures, while Gold Buffalos feature classic designs inspired by the rich heritage of the American West, making both coins distinctive in their visual appeal and numismatic value.

The American Gold Eagle showcases Lady Liberty striding confidently forward with a torch in one hand and an olive branch in the other, symbolizing peace and hope. Its reverse side displays a majestic eagle soaring above a nest, highlighting strength and freedom.

On the other hand, the Gold Buffalo features the revered images of a Native American chief and a majestic buffalo, paying homage to the wildlife and native cultures that once flourished in the American West. These intricate and meaningful designs not only add to the beauty of the coins but also evoke a sense of patriotism and historical significance, making them highly sought after by collectors and investors alike.

Purity and Weight

American Gold Eagles are minted with 22 karat gold, containing a specific weight and gold content, while Gold Buffalos are crafted from 24 karat gold, boasting a higher purity level and gold content in their metal composition.

The difference in karatage between these two iconic coins impacts not only their intrinsic value but also their physical attributes. American Gold Eagles, comprising 91.67% gold and 8.33% copper and silver, are more durable due to the alloy mix, making them resistant to scratches and wear. On the other hand, Gold Buffalos, made of 99.99% pure gold, shine with a radiant luster, reflecting the coin’s pure gold content.

This distinction in metal composition also affects the weight of the coins, with Gold Buffalos typically weighing slightly more than their American Gold Eagle counterparts.

American Gold Eagles hold legal tender status in the United States, with a nominal face value backed by the government, while Gold Buffalos also enjoy legal tender recognition, reflecting the trust and confidence in these coins as valuable assets made from precious coinage metal.

The legal tender status of these coins signifies that they are officially recognized by the government for use as currency, even though their intrinsic value far exceeds their face value. American Gold Eagles are minted in one ounce, half ounce, quarter ounce, and tenth ounce denominations, while Gold Buffalos are typically minted in one ounce sizes. The coinage metal compositions of American Gold Eagles consist of 91.67% gold, 3% silver, and 5.33% copper, while Gold Buffalos are made of .9999 fine gold. This governmental backing adds a layer of credibility and assurance, impacting their desirability in the numismatic market and among collectors.

Availability and Mintage

The availability and mintage figures of American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos vary, with certain editions considered more collectible due to limited mintages or unique design variations, appealing to coin collectors seeking rare and exclusive pieces for their collections.

The limited mintages of these coins play a significant role in their desirability amongst collectors. For instance, special edition releases with lower mintages tend to fetch higher prices in the secondary market, attracting investors looking for potential appreciation in value. The production processes of these coins, which involve meticulous precision and quality control measures, also contribute to their allure. The exclusive distribution channels and marketing strategies adopted by official mints add an element of exclusivity to these coins, further enhancing their collectibility.

What Are the Similarities Between American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos?

Despite their differences, American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos share common ground in their investment value, government backing, and appeal to both collectors and investors seeking reputable precious metal coins with intrinsic worth.

Both coins are guaranteed by the United States government for weight, content, and purity, providing a level of trust and stability for those looking to invest in physical gold. The recognizable designs, such as Lady Liberty on the Gold Eagles and the iconic Buffalo on the Gold Buffalos, contribute to their desirability among numismatists and investors alike. As tangible assets with a long-standing history of holding and growing value, these coins are often seen as a reliable hedge against economic uncertainties and inflation.


Both American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos are crafted from fine gold, ensuring high-quality standards in their coinage metal compositions, making them sought-after assets for individuals looking to invest in physical gold with intrinsic value and purity.

Crafted with a purity of 91.67%, American Gold Eagles have a mix of gold, copper, and silver, providing durability and a distinct reddish hue. On the other hand, Gold Buffalos contain 99.99% pure gold, making them one of the purest gold coins globally. This high level of purity not only adds to the coins’ elegance but also increases their appeal to investors seeking tangible assets with guaranteed purity and value. The meticulous selection of fine gold for these coins underscores the commitment to creating enduring pieces that retain their worth over time, offering a stable investment option in the volatile market scenarios.

Investment Value

Both American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos offer strong investment potential, with a track record of value retention and consistent market demand, making them reliable choices for individuals looking to add precious metals to their investment portfolios.

Investors often turn to American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos due to their intrinsic value and historical significance, which contribute to their enduring appeal in the world of precious metal investments. These coins are recognized globally for their purity and iconic designs, attracting both novice and seasoned investors seeking a tangible asset that can withstand economic uncertainties. The stability of gold prices over time also adds to the attractiveness of these coins, providing a hedge against inflation and market fluctuations. As a result, American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos continue to be sought after for diversification and wealth preservation in investment portfolios.

Government Backing

Both American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos enjoy government backing, instilling confidence in investors and collectors due to their status as official coins sanctioned by the Coinage Act with a legal tender value recognized by the United States government.

This backing by the government not only adds a layer of credibility to these precious metal coins but also assures buyers of the integrity and authenticity of their investment. The United States government backing serves as a guarantee of the coins’ quality and purity, making them highly sought-after in the numismatic and investment markets. Investors and collectors value the stability and assurance that come with owning these coins, knowing that they hold a piece of history coupled with the solid support of the U.S. government.

Which One Should You Invest In: American Gold Eagles or Gold Buffalos?

Deciding between investing in American Gold Eagles or Gold Buffalos depends on factors such as your personal preference, investment goals, and insights into market trends, with each coin offering unique design details and a place in the bullion coin program.

While American Gold Eagles are known for their iconic depiction of Lady Liberty and the American Bald Eagle, which evoke a sense of patriotism and national pride, Gold Buffalos showcase the classic American Buffalo design, paying tribute to the country’s heritage.

In terms of investment potential, Gold Eagles are more widely recognized internationally, potentially offering greater liquidity, while Gold Buffalos are prized for their purity, with gold sourced exclusively from American mines.

Collectors often appreciate the variations in design, with some favoring Eagles for their historical significance and others drawn to Buffalos for their classic appeal.”

Personal Preference

When deciding between American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, personal preference plays a crucial role, as the intricate design details and aesthetic appeal of each coin may resonate differently with individual investors seeking to add precious metals to their portfolios.

The American Gold Eagle, with its iconic Lady Liberty and soaring eagle motifs, often appeals to collectors and investors who appreciate traditional and patriotic designs.

On the other hand, the Gold Buffalo, featuring the renowned Native American Indian Head design and American buffalo, captures the attention of those drawn to historical and artistic representations.

Investors are encouraged to consider not only the weight and purity of the coins but also the emotional connection and visual allure that the designs hold, as these factors can enhance the overall satisfaction and pride in their investment choices.

Investment Goals

Aligning your investment goals with the characteristics of American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos is essential, as both coins offer opportunities for wealth preservation and portfolio diversification, catering to investors seeking bullion coins with investment-grade qualities.

Investors looking to solidify their investment portfolios can benefit from the stability and intrinsic value of these iconic gold coins. American Gold Eagles, known for their U.S. government backing, and Gold Buffalos, prized for their purity and design, present a reliable option for those interested in adding tangible assets to their holdings. These coins are recognized worldwide, providing liquidity and ease of trading in the global precious metals market. By incorporating American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, investors can enhance the resilience of their portfolios against market fluctuations and inflation.

Staying informed about market trends in coin investment and the gold bullion market is crucial when deciding between American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, as evolving market dynamics can influence the value and demand for these iconic coins.

In the world of coin investment, being proactive in monitoring market trends is akin to equipping oneself with a compass in a vast sea. Changes in market conditions can have a ripple effect on the investment potential of American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, directly impacting their pricing and desirability among both seasoned collectors and new investors alike. By staying attuned to market fluctuations, investors can adjust their strategies, seize opportunities, and navigate the ever-changing landscape of precious metal investments with confidence.

How to Purchase American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos?

Acquiring American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos can be done through authorized coin dealers, online retailers specializing in bullion coins, or participating in auctions and private sales, offering various avenues for individuals looking to enter the coin investment market.

Authorized coin dealers provide a direct and reliable source for purchasing these coveted gold coins, ensuring authenticity and quality.

Online bullion coin retailers offer convenience and a wide selection, allowing buyers to browse and purchase from the comfort of their own homes.

Participating in auctions and private sales can sometimes lead to unique finds and potentially better deals, but it requires careful research and evaluation to avoid scams or overpaying.

Each channel has its own advantages and considerations, so investors should weigh their options based on their preferences and risk tolerance.

Authorized Dealers

Authorized dealers serve as reputable sources for acquiring American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, providing assurance in coin authenticity and secure coin storage options for investors and collectors looking to safeguard their precious metal acquisitions.

These dealers play a crucial role in ensuring that individuals can invest in these highly sought-after coins with confidence. By offering coin authentication services, authorized dealers give customers peace of mind knowing that they are purchasing genuine products. These dealers often provide secure storage solutions, allowing investors to store their coins safely and securely. Engaging with authorized dealers not only guarantees the authenticity of the coins but also offers a level of convenience and protection that is invaluable in the world of precious metal investments.

Online Retailers

Online retailers specializing in precious metal coins offer a convenient platform for purchasing American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos, often providing coin grading services and access to the numismatic market for collectors and investors seeking high-quality numismatic coins.

These online platforms not only make it easier for individuals to browse and select from a wide range of numismatic offerings but also ensure transparency in transactions, as buyers can access detailed information about the coins’ condition and value. By leveraging the expertise of coin grading services, collectors and investors can make more informed decisions, knowing the precise quality and authenticity of the coins they are acquiring. This seamless integration of services enhances the overall purchasing experience and cultivates trust among buyers in the online numismatic community.

Auctions and Private Sales

Participating in auctions and private sales presents opportunities to acquire American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos through competitive bidding or direct transactions, with options to secure coin insurance for added protection of valuable numismatic acquisitions.

When engaging in auctions, collectors and investors immerse themselves in an electrifying environment where the thrill of outbidding competitors intensifies the quest for prized coins. The fast-paced nature of auctions requires quick decisions and strategic thinking to secure sought-after pieces amidst stiff competition.

Alternatively, private sales offer a more personalized approach, allowing for direct negotiations with sellers to acquire numismatic treasures without the pressure of bidding wars. Both avenues provide unique routes to build a diverse and valuable collection, with the added benefit of coin insurance to safeguard investments against unforeseen circumstances.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between the American Gold Eagle and the Gold Buffalo?

The American Gold Eagle and Gold Buffalo are both popular gold coins produced by the United States Mint. However, there are some key differences between the two.

What are the designs of the American Gold Eagle and Gold Buffalo?

The American Gold Eagle features a design of Lady Liberty on the obverse and a family of eagles on the reverse. The Gold Buffalo has an obverse design of a Native American chief and a buffalo on the reverse.

Which coin has a higher gold purity?

The American Gold Eagle is made from 22-karat gold, which means it is composed of 91.67% pure gold. The Gold Buffalo is made from 24-karat gold, making it 99.99% pure gold.

Which coin is more valuable?

The value of the American Gold Eagle and Gold Buffalo can vary depending on the current market price of gold. However, in general, the Gold Buffalo is considered to have a higher value due to its higher purity.

Are there any differences in size and weight between the two coins?

Yes, the American Gold Eagle is slightly larger and heavier than the Gold Buffalo. The American Gold Eagle has a diameter of 32.7mm and weighs 1 ounce, while the Gold Buffalo has a diameter of 30.6mm and also weighs 1 ounce.

Both the American Gold Eagle and Gold Buffalo have a loyal following among collectors. However, the American Gold Eagle has been in production for a longer period of time and is considered to be more widely collected.